Skip to main content

Lionel Messi vs Cristiano Ronaldo : Numbers don't lie

Posted by: Jake W

The discussion and decision about who should be awarded the Ballon d’Or for 2012 has been going on for far too long and, to be honest, it is a very simple matter.

Lots of talk about Ronaldo getting it this year because Messi has won it enough…give someone else a chance…But should they really present an award based on making its status equitable to all the deserving players?  You either qualify as the best candidate, or someone else is better than you...  Is the Ballon d’Or a popularity contest or maybe about who carries their presence this way or that on the pitch?  

I am an American across the pond looking on from afar as a lifelong fan of the game.  Having played, coached, and ref’d soccer over the last 40 years or so I think I can contribute a viewpoint here that might help.

There is belief that Ronaldo has every bit the pedigree that Messi has and that its time to balance the ledger.  I certainly have an opinion on this, as does everyone else on this blog, in Spain, in Europe, across the globe.   And that’s the trouble….. everyone has a perspective, a belief, an assertion about this topic.  Debates that place in the arena of verbal joust, twitter feed, training ground speech, or post-game podium quote have no solution.  The only way to compare artistry and brilliance is to achieve a common understanding of the results; and that requires something we here in the States have taken to a sometimes absurd level:  statistics.

Numbers and a baseline set of criteria will see us through to a winner, so what do we go?  
We can agree that numbers are numbers and in most cases can be considered undisputed.  I have used the stats available from ESPN and have cut off updating them as of 11/19/2012:  
To advocate for an award winner we must know what the presenters think.  In the case of FIFA, they are noticeably vague on the subject, only saying that it goes to the player who has performed the best in the previous season.  So let’s discuss this point.  

In the States, we spend a lifetime arguing about our own sports awards.  We endlessly debate the topic of who is the best player at a given sport, and we call that player the MVP, or most valuable player.  In the end, it’s about who provides the most complete package as a player.  Who brings the widest array of talents to the table?  For the Ballon d’Or argument, I say we can use five criteria:  Scoring, Assisting, Durability, Accuracy/efficiency, and Team success.  

Scoring is obvious.  We base our estimate of worth on how much of something a player produces.  The most tangible, highest-valued product a footballer can give us is goals.

Assists are where we thin the herd.  Making your teammates better players is embedded in the MVP talk in America.  If you boost everyone around you, surely you are the best player.  Who has vision on the field? who has the ability to create opportunities for their teammates to succeed?

Durability is staying power.  Score 7 goals in a one game, but play only 5 matches all year, and you cannot be in a best player conversation.  You must prove it day in/ day out. 

Accuracy / efficiency.  Can you count on a player, if given the moment, to succeed?  Is that player deserving of the chance his teammate has created for him.   Someone who blasts 35 shots in a game but forces only 3 saves it not skilled as a shooter.  Aim where you want to hit, and hit what you aim at…
Team success.  Surely the best player in the world cannot be on the last place team in a league.  We already said an MVP helps others succeed.  Thus, by default, a winning team should be the location for the best player.

Now we can look at the data and see what we see.  Using the site mentioned, I pulled data on Messi, Ronaldo, and Falcao and simply applied filters to show relationships.  Those 3 players are the hot tickets in this debate.  Obviously the finalists have been announced and Falcao is no longer in the running, but at the time I started this, he was still a viable candidate.

The amount of analysis possible is beyond the limits of this blog, but to summarize, over the course of the 2012 season through mid-November, Messi had scored 33% more goals than Ronaldo, had made 200% more assists than Ronaldo, had scored his goals using 31% fewer shots on goal than Ronaldo, and had produced his results in 11% fewer games than Ronaldo.

On a per-game basis, Messi has scored 56% more goals per game than Ronaldo, made 239% more assists per game than Ronaldo, scored his goals using 22% fewer shots on goal than Ronaldo, and was 26% more accurate with his shots than Ronaldo.

Clearly, Messi deserves the Ballon d’Or for 2012:  

Messi has outscored Ronaldo, though Ronaldo is having a very impressive scoring year as well.
Messi has excelled as a setup man.  He has a 3-to-1 ratio of assists to Ronaldo and a 5-to-1 ratio to Falcao.  In only 1 year has Ronaldo had more assists, and that was 2006 when Messi played in 50% fewer games than Ronaldo.

Messi and Ronaldo are equally durable and have played almost all their team’s  matches.
Messi is much more dangerous with the ball.  Messi puts the ball on net 57% of time he shoots.  Ronaldo’s on target 45% of the time.  Out of all those shots on goal, Messi scored 56% more goals every game than Ronaldo.  

Messi and Ronaldo are on teams that are at the top of the league or world standings.  But the 2012 season has seen an unbeaten Barcelona side, a world #1 club ranking, and a consistent parade of its players to the podium for league, continent, and world football awards.

Some argue that Messi has an easier time of it at his false 9 position.  This ignores what we see every game with Messi. He is rarely marked just one-on-one inside the 30, he roams sideline to sideline when needed to use space, recover possession, or take throw-ins/corners. There is also one stat not kept that would be a very thorny point for Ronaldo to contest:  the “don’t go down” factor. 

If we watched every minute of every match Messi has played this year, how many “got hit and should of/could of fallen down but kept going and scored/assisted” plays have there been. Messi has the kind of reputation now that some legendary baseball players had in America where they were known to have such a good command of what was a ball and what was a strike while batting that when they mentioned something casually to the umpire about a call being wrong, the umpire seriously considered it. For Messi, when he finally does go down, everyone in the stadium knows it must have been a real foul.

I believe this data and my analysis had some grounding in reason.  Numbers don’t lie, and as a way to evaluate the quality of something in an unbiased way, I believe using boring, unhyped, plain old numbers is the only way to succeed!


Popular posts from this blog

Why Verratti should join Barcelona, Vermaelen fiasco and transfer rumours [TBP#8]

The Barcelona Podcast duo discuss why Barcelona should go the extra mile to sign Marco Verratti. Francesc and Dan also discuss why the time Thomas Vermaelen has spent at Barca must be considered a disaster. The duo also address the latest transfer rumours. Episode 8 of 'The Barcelona Podcast' is finally here!

If you are new here, consider subscribing so that you never miss another update! You can subscribe on iTunes, via your preferred podcast app or on Soundcloud.

Check it out here:

'The Barcelona Podcast' is brought to you by Francesc Tomas (as seen in ESPN, The Guardian) and Dan Hilton (Barcablog). Listen in for our opinionated take on the hottest breaking stories from the Camp Nou!

Why Barcelona should sign Yerry Mina in 2018

Yerry Mina has been heavily linked with Barcelona in recent times. The 22-year-old centre-back, who has excelled for both Palmeiras and Colombia in recent times, is rumoured to be joining Barca in the summer -- the summer of 2018, that is.

Given the huge role Mina is bound to play for Colombia in the biggest international tournament in football, the Barca board believe it is best for the young defender to stay in his current club until then. As per, Los Cafeteros are currently 28/1 favourites to win the World Cup in 2018 and their limited chances of success would only increase if Mina's form and confidence is exceptional when it truly matters.

Barcelona reportedly agreed an option to bring Mina from Palmeiras to the Camp Nou for a €9 million back in October 2016. However, the Barca board believe that the 195cm Colombian should remain in his current club until the end of the 2018 World Cup, to be played in Russian next summer.

The almost certain departure of Jer…

Dani Alves to Manchester City: Another example of terrible business by Barcelona

Dani Alves has been linked with a move to Manchester City and is expected to join the Sky Blues in the coming days. Astute as ever, former Barcelona manager Pep Guardiola has not wasted a second to approach his former star in order to strengthen his squad this summer.

Dani Alves was allowed to leave Barcelona on a free transfer only last season. Considering his continued excellent performances for Juventus, it is obvious why Guardiola is prepared to pay a fee of €5.7 million to reunite with the veteran Brazilian full-back.

Alves' departure can only be considered as terrible business for Barcelona -- and this is certainly not the first time.

It really is baffling that, while Alves is being offered a further two years to move to the English Premier League, Barcelona are still struggling to find a worthy replacement: With stories linking the Blaugranas to Hector Bellerin or Nelson Semedo splashed all over the Catalan media on a daily basis.

We discussed why Bellerin should be the Bl…

Can Riyad Mahrez improve Barcelona's attack?

Riyad Mahrez has been linked to Barcelona for a couple of seasons now. His superb performances for Leicester City, which helped The Foxes conquer the Premier League only last season, made him an attractive addition for major European clubs in need of talent.

Mahrez extended his contract for a further four years with Leicester only last summer, shortly after finishing 7th in the run-up for the Ballon d'Or. While The Foxes have been far less consistent this season, the 26-year-old Algerian international was contributed with four goals and two assists in their Champions League campaign.

Undoubtedly, Mahrez would be a great signing for any club. However, would Barcelona be the best fit for his future? Can he bring what the Catalan giants are currently lacking? Listen to Episode 9 of 'The Barcelona Podcast' to find out:

If you are new here, consider subscribing so that you never miss another update! You can listen on iTunes, via your preferred podcast app or on Soundcloud.

Do …

Lucas Lima is not the midfielder Barcelona need despite Neymar recommendation

Lucas Lima is close to finalising his transfer to Barcelona in January 2018, according to reports in the Brazilian media. The 26 year-old midfielder, who currently plays for Santos and the Brazilian national team, is rumoured to be joining Barca on a free transfer once his current deal expires on 31st December 2017.

Lima has reportedly received offers from Real Madrid, PSG and Bayern Munich in recent times. However, the gifted Santos playmaker is set to sign a four-year deal with Barcelona as soon as July 1st, exactly six months before his contract with Santos expires.

While I don't doubt that the Brazilian international is a quality player, it seems obvious that the fact that his agent is in fact Neymar's dad has helped his potential move to Barcelona. Having dated Neymar's sister and his close friendship with Barca's No.11 would not have done much harm to his chances of securing a move either.

If rumours were to become a reality and Lima joined the Catalan giants du…

The Pique vs Ramos rivalry, Riyad Mahrez rumours and La Masia decline [TBP#9]

The Barcelona Podcast duo discuss whether Riyad Mahrez would be a success if he joined Barca. Francesc and Dan also discuss the bitter rivalry between Gerard Pique and Sergio Ramos. The duo also address the current state of affairs at La Masia. Episode 9 of 'The Barcelona Podcast' is finally here!

If you are new here, consider subscribing so that you never miss another update! You can listen on iTunes, via your preferred podcast app or on Soundcloud.

Check it out here:

Do you know someone who loves Barcelona as much as you do? If so, would you share this podcast with them? That would be awesome, thank you!

'The Barcelona Podcast' is brought to you by Francesc Tomas (as seen in ESPN, The Guardian) and Dan Hilton (Barcablog). Listen in for our opinionated take on the hottest breaking stories from the Camp Nou!

The Barcelona Podcast

Barcelona podcast by Francesc Tomas (ESPN, Barcablog) and Dan Hilton (NYCR), passionate about bring you the hottest breaking stories from the Camp Nou. If you are new here, consider subscribing so that you never miss another Barca update!

SUBSCRIBE on YouTubeLIKE us on Facebook FOLLOW us on Twitter

What Messi's new contract means for Barcelona, Mathieu's future and ideal signings [TBP#7] | The Barcelona Podcast

The Barcelona Podcast duo discuss why Lionel Messi renewing his Barca contract is huge news for the Camp Nou giants. Francesc and Dan also discuss whether Jeremy Mathieu should remain Ernesto Valverde's squad next season. The duo also address the latest transfer rumours. Episode #7 of 'The Barcelona Podcast' is finally here!

This episode is brought to you by FuboTV. We have secured an EXCLUSIVE discount for you to watch hundreds of sporting events, including ALL FC Barcelona matches in HD, at

About 'The Barcelona Podcast' channel: Created by Francesc Tomas (ESPN, Barcablog) and Dan Hilton (Barcablog). We are committed to bringing you the hottest breaking stories from the Camp Nou.

Marco Reus, preferred transfer target for Barca fans | Barcelona News

Barcelona future star Eric Garcia snatched by Manchester City

Eric Garcia, one of the most promising youngsters in Barcelona's La Masia academy, has surprised his coaches by announcing his decision to not renew his current contract.

Garcia is, undoubtedly, one of the most promising defenders in Barca's youth system. The 16-year-old center-back, who is already a Spain U-17 international, has continuously been compared to Gerard Pique during his career at the club -- which started at the tender age of just six years old.

Manchester City are reportedly offering the player €1million over the next three years and, unsurprisingly, are therefore the favourites to land Garcia on a free transfer -- given the fact that Garcia does not have a formal contract with Barcelona given his age.

Cesc Fabregas or Hector Bellerin are only a couple of the players that Barca has lost in this controversial manner over the years. This is unacceptable. La Masia has to be the basis for Barcelona's future, as we discussed in much more depth in Episode 7 of …