Skip to main content

Why Barcelona should consider a 3-5-2 formation


After their disappointing 2-1 defeat in Sevilla, it is clear that Luis Enrique must take measures in order to get Barcelona's season back on track.

For a moment, let us go back in time to 2010. That year, three Barca players, namely, Lionel Messi, Andres Iniesta and Xavi finished on the Ballon d’Or podium. That year, Barca scraped past Sevilla 3–2 at the Ramon Sanchez-Pizjuan en route to the 2009/10 league title. In a match in which none of the three players on the Ballon d’Or podium in 2010 will take part, the result could not have been less encouraging.

Xavi is no longer at the club, while Messi and Iniesta are down in the treatment room. Barcelona’s worst fears have been realised, and after a summer of lull on the transfer front, things are tighter than ever for Luis Enrique’s side, who are chasing a repeat of history this term.

Perhaps the league title might already look a bit too far-fetched this season, but there are plenty reasons to believe why Enrique has the managerial nous to turn things his way despite being on the wrong end of luck in recent weeks.

Without Messi, Barcelona are half the team, and without Iniesta, Barcelona are even lesser than half. This brings to light Enrique’s tactical ingenuity, which could mean a temporary departure from the template 4–3–3.

Barcelona’s 4–3–3 works wonders when the front-3 comprises Messi, Luis Suarez and Neymar. But with Messi out, the MSN trio is bereft of its spine, which in turn makes the 4–3–3 far less effective. Particularly when you consider Munir and Sandro are the options in place of Messi.

Against Bayer Leverkusen in the Champions League on Tuesday, Barca struggled with the high block pressing of the German club, and were lucky to come away with a win after a late rally. That late rally offered enough pointers that 4–3–3 isn’t really the way forward without Messi to draw opponents out.

With the scarcely-used 3–5–2 heavily mooted, it could provide Enrique with an option to fill the round hole with round pegs, rather than putting square pegs as would have been the case with the 4–3–3, or the rough diamonds of Munir or Sandro alongside Neymar and Suarez in attack.

The 3–5–2 fits in perfectly with the personnel at Luis Enrique’s disposal. The three centre-backs can be any three from Gerard Pique, Javier Mascherano, Jeremy Mathieu, Marc Bartra and even Sergio Busquets. While the three in midfield can be filled by Busquets, Sergi Roberto, Ivan Rakitic and Mascherano.

Sergi Roberto, who has been favoured mostly as a right-back this season in the injury-induced absence of Dani Alves, is primarily a box-to-box midfielder but has had to tweak his style and curb his instincts to be part of a team as successful as last season’s Barcelona. And it seems the 23-year-old’s patience and endeavour has finally come to fruition.

Ideally, Roberto alongside Rakitic and a deep-lying Busquets is the midfield of choice if we look at the squad. The trio, who will be flanked by Alves and Jordi Alba as the two wing-backs, provides a nice balance to the line-up. And considering neither Munir nor Sandro will need to be accommodated in the 3–5–2, it is a win-win situation for the club.

Barca have conceded nine goals already this season and four in a single game, and the need for defensive solidity assumes greater importance given the creative tools of Messi are currently unavailable. With the Blaugrana struggling in front of goal, increased defensive solidity is clearly the answer in troubled times.

That is why a three-man defence needs to be deployed by Enrique. Against Celta Vigo in that 4–1 defeat, Barcelona’s back line was heavily exposed as they put numbers forward in attack. With a three-man defence though, chances of getting outnumbered at the back reduce significantly as teams rarely put four up front against Barca.

There are a number of downsides of the 3–5–2 but looking at the larger picture, the pros easily outweigh the cons. Given Neymar will operate in the more congested central zone, and Barca might be subjected to attacks from wide areas, but the 3–5–2 provides a better base to initiate attacking moves when you don’t have the inspiration of Messi.

Sometimes, it’s better to be safe than sorry, and if Enrique is looking to grind out positive results until his talisman returns back from injury, the 3–5–2 formation’s mix of central overloads and better defensive stability means Barca will do well to use that blueprint.

By Abhijit Bharali, columnist at Barcablog. Follow him on Twitter here

Comments

  1. Luis Enrique and Barcelona have reached a point where they have so few players available that a change of formation may be the optimal solution.

    In my eyes, it all depends on whether Munir and Sandro step up and reach a decent enough level to continue with the current, traditionally successful 4-3-3.

    If the La Masia graduates don't respond as well as expected, then the 3-5-2 would make much more sense.

    ReplyDelete
  2. A 4-3-1-2 may be much better wit busquets at d base and roberto and samper as CMs with rakitic in the hole
    This way we dont sacrifice creativity much

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Great Gamble of Barcelona with Dembélé

Recently, a lot has been said about Ousmane Dembélé, the 20 year old French footballer that received worldwide attention after hitting the second most expensive transfer in football history for £97m (from Borussia Dortmund to FC Barcelona), just after the stratospheric £198m move of Neymar Jr. from FC Barcelona to Paris Saint Germain.

Indeed, Dembélé is going to be playing Neymar’s same position and, because of that, media all around the globe have rephrased the same question, asking if the favourite son of Mauritania has what it takes to pay off his transfer price with goals and skills of the quality of Messi, or if his big marketing brand and solid presence on the football field is going to be missed by all of the Barcelona FC fans in the upcoming seasons.


Photo: FC Barcelona via Facebook
Several comments have arisen so far and from very different points of view, starting from the lack of faith in the young player by soccer legends like Arsene Wenger. The Arsenal coach stated that D…

Is Maxime Lopez the heir to the Barcelona midfield?

Maxime Lopez, 19-year-old Marseille midfielder, is the latest name to pop up as a potential successor to Andres Iniesta or Xavi in Barcelona's midfield.

Maxime Lopez plays as an attacking midfielder in Rudi Garcia's 4-3-3 and looks right at home next to bigger names such as Dimitri Payet, Florian Thauvin, Morgan Sanson and Luiz Gustavo. A French youth player with a Spanish father and an Algerian mother, it isn't too far-fetched to think that he would adapt well to Spanish football.

The diminutive midfielder is part of a generation of French footballers that includes Kylian Mbappe, Thomas Lemar and Kingsley Coman. Undoubtedly, Lopez could be the next in the line. After seeing the outrageous totals being thrown about in the most recent transfer market, any team that wants Lopez may want to make a move for him before his price tag soars to unreasonable heights.

The Barcelona Podcast duo talked about the ongoing arms race for young players between FC Barcelona and Real Madrid…

Nelson Semedo only getting better for Barcelona

He may have only started three games for FC Barcelona, but the hype train for Nelson Semedo has already left the station.

A twelve minute cameo against Chapecoense AF in the Joan Gamper Trophy game got him his unofficial Barcelona debut, followed up by a forty minute appearance against Real Madrid in the Spanish Super Cup where he looked like a player getting accustomed to his teammates.

Four days later in the La Liga opener, the Portuguese defender was given his first Barcelona start against Real Betis. He hit 94% of his passes, 52 in total, and seemed to be finding his feet on the right side.

After not featuring against Deportivo Alaves, he was given another start against Espanyol in a 5-0 trouncing of the local rival. His dribbling was less purposeful, but his defending was spot-on in controlling the right side of the field and combining well with Gerard Deulofeu. He still hit 92% of his passes and landed 78 total passes while showing his speed on a few occasions.

With the start a…

Aleix Vidal becoming a victim of Nelson Semedo's excellent form for Barcelona

Aleix Vidal has been left out of the Barcelona's squad that is to play away at Getafe on Saturday for the second consecutive match -- which is disappointing given the fact that the Catalan full-back had, in theory, everything in his favour to establish himself as a regular starter this season.

As it could not be any different, Ernesto Valverde refused to make give the situation much importance when speaking to the media in the Getafe pre-match conference: "Aleix is a player who can help us in more than one position. I understand these type of questions, but it’s likely that I will have to leave one or two players out of the squad on a weekly basis. Aleix started the game against Alaves and, although, he’s not been in the squad for the last two matches, that could change at any moment. I’m happy with him and with his performances."

Undoubtedly, the incredible form that new signing Nelson Semedo has shown of late is having an detrimental effect to Vidal's playing time…

Why Paulinho can be an unexpectedly great partner for Lionel Messi

Paulinho landed at Barcelona after the Blaugranas agreed to pay his whopping €40 million release clause to his previous club, Guangzhou Evergrande from the Chinese Super League. After weeks of endless speculation and an even more significant amount of negative opinions from the vast majority of fans and media, it is clear that the Brazilian was going to face plenty of adversity as soon as he landed at the Camp Nou.

While it is obviously still early days in the season, Paulinho is slowly but surely establishing himself not only as a valid player for Barcelona, but also a real contender to break into Ernesto Valverde's starting lineup on a weekly basis. The Brazilian international's two goals in his last two matches have certainly contributed to Barcelona's impressive start to their La Liga campaign and, judging by his effective performance against Eibar, his presence in the team is very likely to remain a constant for the remainder of the season.

As our The Barcelona Podca…

Paulinho rescues uninspired Barcelona | Quick Reaction and Player Ratings

Barcelona left it late to secure the three points when they visited Getafe on Saturday. The hosts were determined to bring the game to Barca from the initial whistle and, thanks to their high pressing and that crucial extra degree of energy applied, they were ultimately unlucky to come away from the game without a single point to show for their sacrifice.

Ernesto Valverde decided to field his preferred starting eleven with the only exception of Sergi Roberto for the in-form Nelson Semedo. The manager's idea was not as effective as expected, however, given the fact that his Barcelona lineup looked tired throughout the game and, what's worse, disappointigly unfocused during large periods.

Fortunately for Cules, Barca decided to step up a gear in the second half, especially after both Denis Suarez and Paulinho were subbed on. An increase of purposeful passing and success when running at defenders resulted in goals from both subsititutes and yet another three points, extending th…

Can Messi reach new heights under Valverde? Semedo progression, Getafe preview and Maxime Lopez [TBPod33]

The Barcelona Podcast duo review the 3-0 win over Juventus, discuss the signing of Maxime Lopez, preview the Getafe match and give an update on the vote of no confidence. Episode 33 of 'The Barcelona Podcast' is finally here!

Running Order:
Who are the 5 Star Players from the 3-0 win over Juventus?
What makes Jordi Alba and Andres Iniesta so effective under Ernesto Valverde?
How quickly is Nelson Semedo adapting to the Barcelona style?
Why is Lionel Messi excelling under Ernesto Valverde?
What advantages do Barcelona and Real Madrid have in the race to sign Marseille midfielder Maxime Lopez?
What can Barcelona expect when they face Getafe?
How optimistic is Agusti Benedito on his progress with the vote of no confidence?

If you enjoy the podcast and want to be part of it, why not show your support? Learn more at http://TBPod.link/Patreon -- Moltes gràcies!

What did you think about this episode? Leave a comment via Twitter or Facebook and debate with Francesc, Dan and the rest …

Lionel Messi thrashes Eibar to extend Barcelona's perfect start in La Liga | Quick Reaction and Player Ratings

Barcelona achieved a comfortable 6-1 victory against Eibar at the Camp Nou in Matchday 5 of La Liga. Although the game was not spectacular, Barca's effectiveness upfront was the decisive factor that unbalanced the game in the Blaugranas' favour.

As it could not be any different, the ever-present Lionel Messi stole the show once again. The Argentinean star continued to excel in the False 9 role that Ernesto Valverde has granted him, taking full advantage of the many fluid partnerships he is now capable to build from his more central position. As surprisingly as it may sound to most, Messi's constant linking with Paulinho was actually one of the highlights of Barca's attacking transitions.

With Luis Suarez remaining an unused substitute, Barcelona's newly arrived manager decided to trust both Denis Suarez and Gerard Deulofeu as wingers and, given what we saw on the pitch, it is hard to disagree with his decision. Denis was influential throughout the whole game, runn…

Can Barcelona overcome the absence of Dembele? Deulofeu golden chance, Paulinho progression and Cruyff [TBPod34]

The Barcelona Podcast duo break down the disheartening Ousmane Dembele injury, provide in-depth analysis of the games against Getafe and Eibar, discuss Paulinho's role as Barca's saviour and so much more! Episode 34 of 'The Barcelona Podcast' is finally here!

Running Order:
What does Ousmane Dembele's injury mean for Barcelona?
Who could get more minutes with Dembele's injury?
Is it time to trust Paulinho?
Who are the 5 Star Players from the 2-1 win over Getafe?
How will Barcelona match up against Eibar?
What does the new stadium mean for Barcelona B and Barcelona Femeni?
Is Agusti Benedito any closer to the vote of no confidence?

If you enjoy the podcast and want to be part of it, why not show your support? Learn more at http://TBPod.link/Patreon -- Moltes gràcies!

What did you think about this episode? Leave a comment via Twitter or Facebook and debate with Francesc, Dan and the rest of our 700,000-strong FC Barcelona community.

You can also subscribe via em…

Why is Messi excelling under Valverde? Celebrating Semedo, Getafe preview and Maxime Lopez [TBPod33]

The Barcelona Podcast duo review the 3-0 win over Juventus, discuss the signing of Maxime Lopez, preview the Getafe match and give an update on the vote of no confidence. Episode 33 of 'The Barcelona Podcast' is finally here!

Running Order:
Who are the 5 Star Players from the 3-0 win over Juventus?
What makes Jordi Alba and Andres Iniesta so effective under Ernesto Valverde?
How quickly is Nelson Semedo adapting to the Barcelona style?
Why is Lionel Messi excelling under Ernesto Valverde?
What advantages do Barcelona and Real Madrid have in the race to sign Marseille midfielder Maxime Lopez?
What can Barcelona expect when they face Getafe?
How optimistic is Agusti Benedito on his progress with the vote of no confidence?

If you enjoy the podcast and want to be part of it, why not show your support? Learn more at http://TBPod.link/Patreon -- Moltes gràcies!

What did you think about this episode? Leave a comment via Twitter or Facebook and debate with Francesc, Dan and the rest …